Best Practices for Responding to USCIS Requests for Evidence

Image via DALL-E

Receiving a Request for Evidence (RFE) from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) can feel a bit daunting. You might have thought everything was in order, but now USCIS is asking for more documentation. No need to panic, though—this doesn’t mean your application is heading for a rejection. In most cases, it’s just a request for clarity or additional proof. So, how do you respond effectively?

Let’s go through the best practices step-by-step to ensure your response is strong, timely, and positions your case in the best possible light.

1. Hire a Professional to Guide You

When you receive a request for evidence USCIS, the very first thing you should consider is getting help from an immigration attorney or an accredited legal professional. Why? The process can be complex, and the stakes are high. A professional can guide you through the specific requirements USCIS is asking for and help ensure that nothing is missed.

Even if you handled the application on your own up to this point, it might be worth seeking expert help now. They’ll be able to interpret the request in detail, spot potential issues, and guide you through a smooth, timely response.

Don’t risk your case by guessing what evidence to submit—leave it to a pro who knows the system inside and out.

2. Understand the RFE

Now that you’ve enlisted some help (or decided to handle it on your own), it’s time to thoroughly understand the RFE. Take a deep breath and read it carefully. USCIS will outline exactly what they need and why they need it.

Does the RFE ask for financial documents? Proof of relationship? Additional forms? Each RFE is different, so it’s crucial to break down exactly what’s being requested. You’ll want to categorize each point and ensure you address every single one. Missing even one document or requirement could lead to further delays or issues with your application.

3. Gather the Necessary Evidence

Once you’re clear on what USCIS is asking for, start collecting the evidence. Be specific and organized. You don’t want to overwhelm USCIS with unnecessary paperwork, but you also don’t want to under-deliver.

A few tips to keep in mind when gathering documents:

• Relevance matters – Only submit what USCIS asks for. If they want tax returns for the last two years, don’t send tax records for the last five. Stay on point.

• Clarity is key – Make sure documents are legible and translated if necessary. USCIS won’t accept documents in languages other than English without a certified translation.

• Be thorough – For example, if you’re asked to prove a bona fide marriage, don’t just submit one or two photos. Provide a range of evidence—joint bills, lease agreements, wedding photos, and even affidavits from people who know about the relationship.

Being organized and thoughtful in your approach can make all the difference. Think of it as presenting a clear, well-structured case. You’re proving your eligibility, and the more methodically you do so, the better.

4. Write a Cover Letter

A cover letter might seem like a small detail, but it’s an important one. This is your opportunity to summarize the evidence you’re providing and show USCIS that you’ve understood their request.

Your cover letter should:

• Address each point in the RFE.

• Briefly explain the documents you’re including.

• Be polite, professional, and concise.

This letter essentially serves as a roadmap for USCIS to follow. The more organized and clear it is, the easier it will be for them to process your response.

5. Submit Your Response on Time

USCIS gives you a deadline for a reason. Failing to meet it could result in a denial of your application, so it’s critical to respect that timeline. Make sure you allow enough time to gather everything, review it, and send it in well before the deadline.

If you anticipate delays in gathering evidence, you can request an extension, but this isn’t guaranteed. It’s best to work quickly and efficiently to avoid any last-minute scrambles.

When submitting, keep copies of everything you send for your records. Use a trackable delivery method to ensure USCIS receives your package, and don’t forget to double-check that everything they’ve asked for is included.

What Happens After You Submit?

Once you’ve sent your response, it’s back to waiting. USCIS will review the additional evidence, and this can take some time, so be patient. In most cases, they will process the response and continue with your application.

Remember, receiving an RFE is not the end of the road. Many applicants receive RFEs and go on to successfully get their visas, green cards, or other immigration benefits. It’s simply part of the process, and with a thoughtful, complete response, you can put your case back on track.

Keep Calm and Stay Focused

Responding to a USCIS RFE is all about being clear, organized, and thorough. By understanding the request, gathering the right evidence, and submitting a well-structured response, you’ll be taking important steps towards a successful application.

Subscribe to our newsletter and explore insightful conversations on workplace culture, burnout, and leadership at the Breakfast Leadership Network, ranked in the top 20 globally. Join us to thrive in the modern work environment.

Please stay connected with us. Check out the Breakfast Leadership Show Podcast for more insights and valuable content. Join our podcast and get inspired by top industry leaders’ leadership lessons and success stories.