6 Reasons Your Clicks Are Resulting In The Wrong Actions

Image via DALL-E

You’ve got visitors clicking through your website, but they’re not taking the actions you want. It can be frustrating—you’ve put time and effort into crafting your site, so why aren’t those clicks turning into meaningful actions? If you’re seeing visitors bounce off without converting, or they’re performing actions that aren’t quite what you intended, something might be amiss with your site’s design or user experience.

Let’s dig into six of the most common reasons your clicks aren’t delivering the outcomes you want, and how you can tackle each one effectively.

1. Unclear Call-to-Actions (CTAs)

If users aren’t clicking on your CTAs—or worse, they’re clicking but not doing what you intended—the problem might lie with how clear and actionable your CTAs are. Let’s face it, your users are scanning through content quickly, so your CTA needs to grab attention and communicate what’s in it for them instantly.

Is your CTA easy to find, and does it clearly tell users what they’ll get by clicking? Ambiguous words like “Click Here” or “Learn More” don’t provide the motivation people need to take action. A better approach is to be specific. For example, if you’re offering a free guide, make the CTA something like “Download Your Free Guide.” This way, users know exactly what they’ll receive with just one click.

2. Misleading Links or Button Text

Ever clicked on a link, expecting one thing, only to end up somewhere completely different? That’s a quick way to lose trust. Misleading link text can happen when buttons or hyperlinks don’t match what’s on the other side. If your users expect to reach a product page but land on a blog post, you’re disrupting their journey.

Each link or button should accurately reflect the destination. It’s also essential to test your links regularly. As experts like Conversion SEO will confirm, outdated URLs, broken links, or redirections to the wrong pages can frustrate visitors and drive them away. Ensuring that your link text and actual link destination align perfectly will make your site feel more intuitive and user-friendly. 

3. Overwhelming Choices on the Page

When people have too many choices, it can lead to decision fatigue. If your site is overloaded with buttons, links, and offers, users might feel unsure of where to click, leading them to either make random, unhelpful clicks or leave altogether. A homepage with ten clickable options might seem like it offers freedom, but it can actually overwhelm visitors.

Consider simplifying the number of options on each page. You don’t need to offer every possible action on your homepage. Guide users through a journey by focusing each page on one main action you want them to take. Not only does this make navigation easier, but it also directs users toward the path that brings them closer to a conversion.

4. Lack of Trust-Building Elements

Conversions require trust, and if your users don’t feel confident about your brand, they’re unlikely to take meaningful actions on your site. Trust signals—like testimonials, certifications, security badges, and transparent contact information—help reassure visitors they’re in a safe place.

Imagine visiting a website and being asked to enter sensitive information without seeing any security badges or customer reviews. Would you feel comfortable? Probably not. Building in small but significant trust markers throughout your site helps make visitors feel secure. Think of it as creating a digital environment where users know they’re interacting with a credible, professional source.

5. Poor Mobile Optimization

With more people browsing on mobile than ever, having a site that works well on mobile is non-negotiable. If your site isn’t optimized for smaller screens, clicks could be going awry. Maybe your links are too small, or CTAs aren’t visible without a lot of scrolling. Mobile visitors are looking for fast, easy navigation, and without it, they’ll likely leave before taking the right action.

To ensure your site is truly mobile-friendly, it’s essential to test it on multiple devices. Make sure buttons are large enough for thumbs, CTAs are prominent, and the layout adjusts seamlessly. Small tweaks can make a big difference in directing mobile visitors toward the right actions.

6. Slow Page Load Times

Imagine clicking on a link and waiting, and waiting... and waiting. The longer your page takes to load, the more likely visitors are to abandon it. Studies show that even a one-second delay can reduce conversions significantly. When users have to wait, they get frustrated, and many won’t stick around to take any action at all.

Check your page load times using tools like Google PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix. If your site isn’t loading within a few seconds, look into optimizing images, removing heavy scripts, and considering a faster hosting solution. Fast load times not only improve the user experience but also increase the likelihood of users sticking around long enough to convert.

Conclusion

Getting visitors to click is just one part of the journey; guiding them to the right actions takes a little more finesse. By clarifying CTAs, ensuring links lead where they should, reducing overwhelming choices, building trust, optimizing for mobile, and improving page speed, you can start transforming those clicks into valuable actions. Remember, even small adjustments can lead to big improvements.

Subscribe to our newsletter and explore insightful conversations on workplace culture, burnout, and leadership at the Breakfast Leadership Network, ranked in the top 20 globally. Join us to thrive in the modern work environment.

Please stay connected with us. Check out the Breakfast Leadership Show Podcast for more insights and valuable content. Join our podcast and get inspired by top industry leaders’ leadership lessons and success stories.